Invited
What every invited agent sees
Hidden until you shortlistExample Heights area
- Single-family
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- 1,640 sq ft
- Street address
- Photos
- Your name
- Phone and email
How it works
Hour by hour, what happens.
Post your home free. Up to 5 local agents send you a written pitch. Compare them side by side, then talk only to the ones you pick.
- Up to 5 written pitchesFive spots per home. Sometimes fewer agents are free to take one.
- Answers within 6 hoursEach invited agent says yes or no within 6 hours, not counting 9 PM to 8 AM.
- 24 hours to writeEvery agent who accepts gets the same full day, from their own acceptance, so nobody is rushed.
- Replacements for 72 hoursIf an agent says no, we invite another, until 72 hours after your home goes live.
From posting to choosing
Your fiveStep 1 of 10
Your first 72 hoursHour 0
0h6h24h48h72h
Five spots, open. Nothing goes out yet.
Day 1, about 3 minutes
Step 1: Post your home
Tell us the basics: property type, beds, baths, size, condition and your timeline. Add up to 3 questions of your own for every agent to answer. Already know an agent? Name up to 2 and they pitch on the same terms as everyone else. Posting is free.
Before anything goes out
Step 2: We check that you own it
You confirm your email and your phone with a code, and our team checks the owner name against county land records within 24 hours. Nothing reaches an agent before that.
When your home goes live
Step 3: We invite up to 5 local agents
We invite verified agents who serve your area and your kind of home, never two from the same team. Agents with recent listing experience, checked against records, are invited first, and one spot is open to any verified agent. Any agents you named take their spots first. Nobody can pay to be invited.
Within 6 hours
Step 4: Each agent accepts or declines
An invited agent has 6 hours to answer. That clock pauses overnight, from 9 PM to 8 AM, so an invitation sent late at night is answered the next day.
24 hours from accepting
Step 5: Each agent writes their pitch
An agent who accepts gets 24 hours from that moment to send you a written pitch on the same four P's: Pricing, Preparation, Presentation, Price. Every agent gets the same full day.
Up to 72 hours after going live
Step 6: Open spots are filled again
If an agent declines, does not answer or gives the spot back, we invite another in their place. Replacement invitations stop 72 hours after your home goes live, or sooner once 5 are in.
As they come in
Step 7: Read each pitch as it lands
Each pitch shows up as a lettered card, A to E. The letters are random and say nothing about who is better or who answered first. Your home page shows how many are ready, being written and being invited. Stop inviting anytime; agents already writing get to finish.
When every agent is done
Step 8: See who they are, shortlist up to 3
Once no more agents are being invited and everyone who accepted has finished, every agent's name and photo show and you compare the pitches side by side. Letters first, so you judge each plan before the name on it. Shortlisting lets you message them, and only then do they see your address and photos.
Before you choose
Step 9: Ask for changes
Once every agent is done, you can ask any agent to change one term, like the fee, open houses or how long the listing agreement runs. They accept, decline or counter. You can also ask a shortlisted agent for a pricing report: your home value, with comps, sent only to you.
Whenever you are ready
Step 10: Choose your agent
Choosing an agent shares your phone and email with them, and you sign the listing agreement with their brokerage, outside PitchToList. Agents you don't choose are told for you.
80% of home sellers contacted just one agent. Give yourself a choice.
Get pitches from agents with verified selling experience. Compare their plans, fees and track records before choosing.
Who gets invited, and why.
Same rules for every home.
Verified
Active license, confirmed brokerage, good standing.
The PitchToList bar
10 sales in 12 months and 7 sold listings in 24, checked against records. Agents who meet it are invited first.
One open spot
One of the five is open to any verified agent, so a strong pitch is never shut out by a sales count. You judge it on the pitch and the checked record, like the rest.
A fair draw
One per team. Reliability counts. Money never does.
See an example draw
Closed sales, past 12 monthsExample agents near one homeExample agents
Invited firstStandard bar: 3 sales in 12 monthsStandard: 3 in 12 moOpen spot onlyOur bar: 10 sales in 12 monthsOur bar: 10 in 12 moFill open spots
Your five
- A
- B
- C
- D
- E
Our bar fills 4 spots, and 1 goes to an agent below it. One per team, in rotation, and every pitch looks the same.
Source: National Association of REALTORS®, 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (sellers who sold July 2024 to June 2025): 80% of recent sellers contacted only one agent before finding the agent they worked with.
What agents see, stage by stage
The same listing card, at the three moments it changes. Your phone and email move only when you share them or choose an agent.
Hidden until you shortlistShortlisted
What a shortlisted agent sees
Shortlisted789 Example Road
Jordan Example · 12 photos · Messages open
- Single-family
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- 1,640 sq ft
- Phone and email, unless you share them
Chosen
What the agent you choose sees
Chosen789 Example Road
Jordan Example · 12 photos · Phone and email shared
- Single-family
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- 1,640 sq ft
Nothing changes for the agents you did not choose.
How to choose
One pitch, and the four places to look.
Maya Brennan
Harbor & Pine · Example pitch
Homes here sell on character and light. I start with a stager walkthrough.
The four P's
- Pricing
- Detailed CMA, priced at market value
- Preparation
- Stager walkthrough, declutter plan
- Presentation
- Twilight photos, video, floor plan
- Price
- 2.5% of the sale price
Your questions
We have a tenant until June. How would you handle showings?
Two showing windows a week, agreed with the tenant in writing, and a courtesy gift at move-out. I have done this four times this year.
Shortlist
Messages open once you shortlist. Only you can start one.
No pitch gives you a home value, so nobody wins your listing by naming the highest number. Want one? Ask a shortlisted agent for a pricing report, with comps, sent only to you.
Free, all of it.
Agents pay a flat fee per pitch, and nobody owes us a cut of your sale: no referral fee, ever. Nothing they pay changes who is invited or how their pitch is shown.
- Posting your home
- Reading and comparing every pitch
- Shortlisting up to 3 and messaging them
- Asking for changes and pricing reports
- Choosing your agent
Agents pitch.You pick.
No calls. Your info never sold. Free for sellers.